Binary Dinosaurs Computer Museum
titlebar
button1Museum History button2Museum Updates button3BinarySaurs on Twitter button4Adverts&Reviews button5Moan, Bitch, Gripe scroll1
button6Inhabitants button7Reviews button8WOW! button9Contact button10Recursion 2017 scroll2
button11Links button12Retro2017 button13BDonFacebook button14CGE-UK 2004 button15WROCC 2006 scroll2
button16DECBOX button17Floppy Recreation spaaaaace spaaaaace spaaaaace scroll3
base blank_textbox

Recreating Floppy Disks
Background
One of the problems of restoring vintage machines goes beyond the actual fixing of the hardware. Once the machine in question is powered up and running what next? Networking was something reserved for the enterprise, universities and research establishments while your average home or small business machine would boot from an 8" or 5.25" floppy disk. Over time these original floppies have degraded purely because they're simple bits of plastic covered in a magnetic oxide that were never really well cared for later in the late 80s as better and more convenient tech took over.
Age has also affected the drives themselves, a perennial problem with equipment this old is the drying out of electrolytic capacitors that leak and either stop working or damage the boards they're soldered to. This plagues owners of vintage machines because unlike a computer which has some form of output device (display, diagnostic LEDs etc) a floppy drive has nothing. If it's not working it won't read disks, but also is it the media itself that's faulty or the controller in the machine itself? Power supply?
A baseline known working machine is needed that can be configured as a source or destination for the many disk images that are available out on the web for a multitude of machines from the Altair through the Research Machines 380Z to the Tandy range and beyond. I've been half-heartedly attempting to write images for various machines over the years without actually learning the mechanisms involved so when something failed it was 'probably' the drive I was using or 'maybe' a bad disk image.
Isn't it easy?
Some platforms make floppy recreation relatively easy thanks to the vintage collecting community that has come up with some excellent ways of bringing machines fully back to life using the old serial protocol known as RS232. Older Apples have the luxury of ADTPro which can baremetal boot an Apple ][, //e, //GS over a serial link from a Mac or PC then let you transfer floppy disk images over the same serial link to genuine 5.25" disks which you can then boot natively. ADTPro also allows use of 'virtual disk' images that appear locally as hard drives.
8-bit Atari machines with floppy drives like the Atari 810 have several options available, the simplest being the SIO2PC which can be made at home for pennies then run in conjunction with a PC-based disk image server like APE.
CP/M machines had a built-in capability to transfer between machines via RS232 but for that to work you needed a working boot disk so how do you get one of those if your machine came without disks? Thankfully a company called Sydex Inc in the US produced ANADISK and TELEDISK, a pair of excellent utilities that could analyse unknown floppies and create disk images which could then be rewritten to new disks. TELEDISK was shareware but in the 90s Sydex sold up and disappeared so vintage machine collector Dave Dunfield created an open source version called ImageDisk that these days is the default go-to for disk image manipulation.
In Practice
However, having the tools to recreate disks is one thing, but hardware is still needed for actual disk writing. My catalyst for researching the required hardware was restoring my RML 380Z which despite having double density 5.25" drives only supported 80k single density disks.
Ignoring 8" floppies, disks came in these formats: The vast majority of disk controllers found in PCs from the early 80s up to the late 90s could only deal with the lower 4 formats because who needs single density? Earlier dual drive machines like the Tandy TRS80 Model 4P allowed the substitution of a double density drive for drive 1 to get the best of both worlds. In addition to the different disk capacities the drives themselves come in various different capabilities but are mostly classed as 40 or 80 tracks running at 300 (SD,DD) or 360RPM (HD). The two most recommended drives these days are the TEAC FD55 and the YE-Data YD380 which seems to be a good all-rounder.
Dave Dunfield and the Classic Computer Collectors community have been collating a list of boards that will do most if not all of the 'old' formats, the most up to date version as at March 2018 is here. Since I already had an old ISA PC running Win98 I tracked down one of the Adaptec boards listed, the AHA-1524CF, only to discover there's two variants of this board, one with a National floppy controller and one with an Intel controller. Only the National controller will write single density disks. Guess which one I got.
In the end I bought an Abit KV8Pro board because it contains a Winbond W83627HF SuperIO controller that works well with older disk formats. I installed an Athlon64 processor, 2GB RAM and a Radeon graphics card then loaded Windows 98. Win98 is needed because ImageDisk and other imaging tools need direct access to the hardware to be able to work which is something Windows2000, XP and above don't allow. With Win98 you can boot to pure DOS 7.0 which makes life easier. This in itself led to the discovery that Win98 has a maximum RAM limit of around 768MB and will crash on a multi-GB machine. The answer to this was a freeware version of HIMEM.SYS which will let you force a configurable limit on upper RAM. I also installed Linux Mint 18 so I have a nice networked dual boot system that I can download images to and put them directly into the Win98 partition then reboot to DOS 7 and go from there. The shareware versions of ANADISK and TELEDISK can still be found online and ImageDisk is a must. For 5.25" drives themselves I already had a Mitsubishi M4853 Dual Density and a Mitsubishi MF504C High Density which sprang back into life after I replaced all the leaked capacitors on the motor control board.
*update* - I now also have a YE-Data YD380 which is working nicely too.
Other things to beware of are:
8" Drives
Successful testing with a drive from my CPT 8520 and an FDADAP shows I can now dump 8" floppies as long as they're not DEC RX02 format. The only thing I needed to do to the Tandon TM848-01 drive was undo its soldered factory settings so I could add jumpers to enable motor control under device select. The CPT does things differently. Unfortunately I can't test writing as my 'new' box of disks has suffered from bitrot or been stored badly before I got them since they appear to have distemper though it could just be the magnetic coating of the disk breaking down. Shame
Pictures

All images and text © Adrian Graham 1999-2018 unless otherwise noted using words. Also on